Making Payment to China: Paying Chinese Suppliers in RMB
In today’s trading landscape with China, choosing the right currency to pay suppliers—whether it’s RMB, USD, or GBP—can significantly impact your bottom line.
Recent fluctuations in the USD/CNH exchange rate have brought this decision into sharper focus.
Table of Contents
Why Paying Chinese Suppliers in RMB?
Paying Chinese suppliers in RMB (Renminbi), also known as the Chinese Yuan (CNY), can be advantageous in several ways:
- Reduced Currency Risk: When you pay in RMB, you avoid currency exchange rate fluctuations between your currency and the supplier’s currency (typically USD). This stability can simplify financial planning and reduce costs associated with currency conversion.
- Cost Savings: Some suppliers may offer discounts or preferential pricing if you pay in their local currency (RMB). This is because they save on currency conversion fees and potential risks associated with currency fluctuations.
- Convenience: If you have operations or investments in China, keeping funds in RMB can simplify accounting and financial management processes. It also facilitates smoother transactions within the local market.
How to Pay to Chinese Suppliers in RMB?
1. Bank Wire Transfer (SWIFT)
Description: A common method for international payments, especially for large amounts.
Process: You can initiate a wire transfer in RMB from your local bank to the supplier’s Chinese bank account. The payment is sent through the SWIFT network, but note that banks will usually convert your local currency into RMB.
Pros: Secure and suitable for large transactions.
Cons: High fees and potentially poor exchange rates.
2. Alipay Cross-Border
Description: Alipay offers cross-border payment services, allowing international buyers to pay in RMB.
Process: You need to set up an Alipay account, add funds, and select a currency conversion option to pay the supplier in RMB.
Pros: Convenient for small and medium transactions.
Cons: Requires account setup and verification.
3. WeChat Pay Cross-Border
Description: Similar to Alipay, WeChat Pay is widely used in China and supports cross-border payments.
Process: You can use your WeChat Pay account to pay suppliers directly in RMB if the supplier is registered for cross-border transactions.
Pros: Easy for smaller transactions, and many Chinese suppliers are familiar with WeChat Pay.
Cons: WeChat Pay account setup can be challenging for non-Chinese residents.
4. Third-Party Payment Platforms (e.g., PayPal)
Description: PayPal and similar services sometimes allow payments in RMB, depending on the supplier’s setup.
Process: You pay via PayPal, and the supplier receives RMB after PayPal’s conversion.
Pros: Fast and convenient, with buyer protection.
Cons: High transaction fees and poor exchange rates.
5. Currency Conversion Services (e.g., Wise)
Description: Services like Wise (formerly TransferWise) offer low-cost currency conversions and transfers in RMB.
Process: Use Wise to convert your local currency into RMB and then transfer it to the supplier’s account in China.
Pros: Lower fees and better exchange rates than traditional banks.
Cons: Account setup and KYC (Know Your Customer) verification are required.
6. Local Partner or Agent in China
Description: Some businesses work with a local partner or a procurement agency in China who pays the suppliers on their behalf in RMB.
Process: You pay your agent in your local currency, and they handle the RMB payment to the supplier.
Pros: Simplifies the process, as the agent handles currency conversions and local transfers.
Cons: May involve additional service fees.
7. RMB Account in Local Bank
Description: Some international banks allow you to open a multi-currency account, including RMB.
Process: You can directly transfer RMB to the supplier if your bank supports RMB-denominated accounts.
Pros: No currency conversion fees if you hold RMB.
Cons: Limited availability, depending on your country and bank.
8. Letters of Credit (LC)
Description: For large transactions, using an LC guarantees payment upon fulfilling the contract.
Process: Your bank issues an LC in RMB, and the supplier receives the funds when they meet the agreed-upon terms.
Pros: Secure and common for high-value purchases.
Cons: Complex and costly for small orders.
“If you use underground banking networks, casinos, or engage in money laundering schemes to obtain cheaper RMB for paying your supplier, their bank account could be frozen. This can result in your supplier being unable to access the funds, jeopardizing the payment for your goods.”
Challenges and Considerations When Using RMB in China Export Transactions
Indeed, if you use RMB through a corporate account to pay Chinese suppliers and treat the transactions as domestic, this can complicate the standard export process.
In China, exporting goods generally involves a series of export approvals, tax, and customs processes, which are standardized when using foreign currency payments.
Here are some specific issues and considerations when using RMB for domestic payments that might affect the regular export process:
Issues with Export Tax Rebates
- Ineligibility for Export Tax Rebates: The Chinese government offers tax rebates to encourage exports for certain exported goods. If a transaction is treated as a domestic sale, these tax rebate benefits cannot be accessed, increasing the cost of the products.
Goods Circulation and Regulation
- Export Control Regulations: Exporting goods from China requires export customs declaration and must comply with export goods regulatory requirements. Payments made in RMB that are treated as domestic transactions may not go through proper export customs, leading to inability to export goods regularly.
- Goods Circulation Issues: If goods circulate without proper export procedures, it could lead to inspections and fines from customs and other regulatory bodies.
Currency Liquidity and Fund Security
- Issues with Fund Liquidity: Domestic transactions may involve stricter controls on fund flows and currency exchange, especially for large sums.
- Fund Security Concerns: Domestic transactions might require additional financial and legal safeguards to ensure fund security, particularly in cross-border transactions.
Tax and Regulatory Considerations
When paying suppliers in China, businesses should be aware of the tax and regulatory implications:
-
- VAT (Value Added Tax): In China, VAT on goods is typically 10-13%. If you are importing goods, your supplier may include VAT in their invoices. Paying in RMB does not exempt you from these taxes; however, understanding VAT regulations can help you optimize your tax strategy and potentially claim back some of these costs.
Paying Chinese Suppliers: Methods, Risks, and Cost Optimization
1. Comparing Paying Chinese Supplier Methods
When paying Chinese suppliers, businesses can choose from a variety of payment methods, each with distinct advantages and disadvantages:
- Alipay & WeChat Pay: These digital payment platforms are widely used in China for small to medium-sized transactions. They offer quick processing times and low fees, but are less suitable for large international transactions due to limits on foreign funds. Alipay and WeChat Pay are highly convenient for paying suppliers in China directly but may require a Chinese bank account or partnership with a local payment intermediary.
- PayPal: PayPal offers buyer protection, making it a popular choice for international transactions. However, fees can be relatively high, especially when converting currencies or withdrawing money from PayPal to a bank account. It is more suitable for small to medium payments and those looking for additional security.
- Wire Transfer: This is a standard method for larger payments and typically used in international trade. Wire transfers, while secure, can take 3-5 business days to process and may incur significant bank fees, especially when currency conversion is involved. They also offer less buyer protection compared to services like PayPal.
- Letters of Credit (LC): This method is often preferred for high-value transactions as it provides security to both the buyer and the supplier. The buyer’s bank guarantees the payment, but LC can be time-consuming and expensive to set up, making it less ideal for smaller purchases.
2. Risk Mitigation with Made in China Payment Methods
Choosing the right payment method can help mitigate risks like fraud or payment disputes.
For instance:
- Escrow Services: Escrow services, where payment is held by a third party until the buyer confirms receipt and satisfaction with the goods, provide a high level of security. This is especially useful for new business relationships. However, it may not always be accepted by Chinese suppliers due to the involvement of third-party agencies, which can delay fund release.
- China RMB Payment Agent Services: These intermediaries can facilitate RMB payments and ensure that funds are properly transferred to the supplier. They are particularly useful when companies do not have a Chinese bank account or want to avoid complications with currency conversion. By using an intermediary, businesses reduce the risks of direct international transfers and enjoy smoother transactions.
- Alipay and WeChat Pay: Though primarily used for smaller payments, these platforms offer integrated risk management features, including payment tracking and refund options in case of disputes.
Selecting a payment method with risk-reducing features like escrow or using reputable agents can greatly minimize the chances of losing funds or receiving unsatisfactory goods.
3. Cheapest Ways to Pay Chinese Suppliers
Reducing transaction costs is crucial for businesses that frequently pay suppliers in China. Here’s a brief cost comparison:
- Wire Transfer: Wire transfers often have higher upfront fees ($25-$50 per transfer), but they are ideal for large sums as the percentage of the transaction fee decreases with larger amounts.
- Alipay/WeChat Pay: These digital platforms usually offer lower fees for small to medium transactions. Alipay, for example, charges around 1.5-2% in fees for international transactions. WeChat Pay has similar low fees, but may require a local intermediary.
- PayPal: Although PayPal is user-friendly, its transaction fees can reach up to 4.5% of the total amount, particularly if currency conversion is involved. It is better suited for one-off or smaller transactions.
- China RMB Payment Agent Services: Agents may charge a commission of 3.5-6%, but this service can streamline the payment process, save time, and provide a more cost-effective solution than traditional wire transfers for mid-sized transactions.
A China RMB payment agent service acts as an intermediary that helps businesses outside of China make payments to Chinese suppliers in RMB.
These services are especially useful for businesses that do not have direct access to Chinese banking facilities or those looking to streamline their payment processes to ensure compliance with Chinese regulations.
4. Pay to Chinese Suppliers Processing Time
The processing time for different payment methods varies, and this can affect your ability to pay suppliers on time, which is critical for maintaining good relationships and avoiding delays in shipments.
- Wire Transfers: Typically take 3-5 business days, depending on the country and bank. While secure, this might be too slow for urgent orders.
- Alipay/WeChat Pay: Almost instantaneous for domestic payments within China. For international transfers, these platforms still offer faster processing times than traditional banking methods, usually within 1-2 days.
- PayPal: Transactions are processed quickly, usually within 24 hours, but moving funds from PayPal to your bank account may take an additional 2-3 days.
- China RMB Payment Agent Services: Payment agents often provide faster services by leveraging local banking channels, making them a good option for timely payments.
By choosing a payment method that matches the urgency of your orders, you can ensure that suppliers are paid on time without risking shipment delays.
5. Emerging Digital Payment Platforms
As digital financial technology evolves, more platforms are emerging that cater to international payments.
These platforms often provide better conversion rates and lower fees than traditional banking methods.
Some examples include:
- TransferWise (Wise): Offers low-cost international transfers with transparent currency conversion rates, making it ideal for businesses that frequently need to convert between currencies like USD and RMB.
- Airwallex: A digital payment platform tailored to businesses, offering cross-border payment solutions with minimal fees and access to real-time exchange rates. It’s particularly useful for companies without a physical presence in China.
These emerging platforms are giving businesses more flexibility and cost-effective options when paying suppliers internationally.
Conclusion:
When purchasing goods from Chinese suppliers, transactions typically involve USD, GBP, or the Chinese yuan (RMB/CNY/CNH).
However, with the yuan depreciating against the USD since spring 2023, businesses are reassessing the wisdom of sticking with traditional USD or GBP payments versus switching to RMB, the official currency of mainland China.
Here’s what businesses need to consider:
- Impact of Exchange Rate Fluctuations: Since spring 2023, the USD/CNH rate has risen by almost 7%, boosting earnings for suppliers invoiced in stable USD. This means suppliers receive more RMB for the same USD transactions, potentially affecting your purchasing power.
- Buffering Against Exchange Rate Volatility: Chinese suppliers often include a buffer in their USD pricing to guard against currency swings, protecting their profit margins. This practice complicates decisions for importers aiming to optimize payment currencies.
- Optimizing Payment Choices: Supplyia recommends businesses explore dual-currency invoicing, offering invoices in both USD and RMB. This flexibility allows businesses to choose the more advantageous currency at payment time, balancing risk and cost-effectiveness.